Will My Car Insurance Rates Go Up After an Accident?

Roman Austin | November 10, 2025 | Car Accidents

After the initial shock of a car accident, a second wave of anxiety often hits. It is a financial fear, a persistent worry that echoes long after the sound of the crash has faded. 

You find yourself asking, “Now that this has happened, will my car insurance rates go up after an accident?” This question is a major source of stress for people across Clearwater and the entire Tampa Bay area. 

The uncertainty of a potential premium increase can feel like adding insult to injury, making you hesitate to take the steps necessary to protect yourself, both medically and financially.

Protecting your premium

The connection between a car crash and your insurance rates is not as automatic as many people believe. Several factors influence the outcome, and knowing them can empower you.

• The single most important factor is fault. A claim against an at-fault driver’s policy should not raise your rates, while a claim where you are at fault very well might.
• Florida is a no-fault state, meaning your own PIP insurance covers your initial injuries. While filing a PIP claim alone should not trigger a rate hike, insurers may view it as part of a larger risk profile.
• The severity of the accident and your prior driving history also play a significant part in an insurer’s decision.
• An experienced car accident attorney can fight an incorrect fault determination by an insurance company, which is a key way to protect yourself from an unjust rate increase.

The Deciding Factor: Who Was At Fault?

The question of fault is the bedrock upon which most insurance decisions are built. While it may seem straightforward at the scene, insurance companies have a complex process for assigning legal responsibility, and their conclusions directly impact your wallet.

Understanding Florida’s no-fault system

The term “no-fault” causes a great deal of confusion. It does not mean that no one is ever at fault for an accident. Florida’s no-fault law, also known as the Personal Injury Protection (PIP) system, governs how you receive compensation for your initial medical injuries. 

It requires you, regardless of who caused the crash, to first turn to your own car insurance policy for up to $10,000 in medical and disability benefits. Imagine you are stopped at a red light on Gulf-to-Bay Boulevard and another driver rear-ends you. Clearly, the other driver is 100% at fault. 

Even so, the no-fault law dictates that your own PIP insurance is the primary payer for your first $10,000 in medical bills. This system was designed to reduce minor lawsuits and ensure that injured individuals receive immediate medical care without first having to prove fault.

When “at-fault” matters for your rates

The concept of fault becomes paramount when dealing with vehicle repairs and injuries that exceed your PIP coverage. If the other driver was at fault, their liability insurance is responsible for paying for your vehicle repairs, your medical bills beyond what your PIP covered, and your pain and suffering. 

This is known as a “third-party claim.”

When you make a claim against another driver’s policy because they were at fault, your insurance company is not the one paying. Therefore, this type of not-at-fault claim should not be a reason for your insurer to raise your rates. 

You are not costing your own insurance company money for the liability portion of the claim, so they have no financial justification to increase your premium.

The insurer’s investigation process

Insurance companies do not simply take your word for what happened. They conduct their own investigation to determine legal fault. An adjuster will be assigned to the case, and their objective is to gather facts that allow their company to pay out as little as possible.

This investigation is a detailed process. The adjuster will request the official police report, which provides the officer’s initial assessment of the crash. They will contact you and the other driver to get statements, and they will try to interview any independent witnesses listed on the report. 

They will also analyze photographs of the vehicle damage and the accident scene to look for physical evidence that supports one version of events over another. This is why having your own advocate is so beneficial; a law firm conducts its own parallel investigation to protect your interests.

Types of Claims and Their Impact on Your Insurance Rates

The type of claim you file is directly related to whether you can expect a rate increase. The source of the payment, whether it is your own policy or the other driver’s, is the key difference.

Filing a claim under your own PIP coverage

As established, you must use your PIP benefits for your initial medical treatment. The question is, can this cause your rates to go up? Legally, an insurer cannot raise your rates solely for a not-at-fault PIP claim. 

However, insurers collect vast amounts of data. They may see the claim as an indicator that you are a higher-risk driver, which could be one of several factors they use to justify a rate increase at your next renewal period.

Your PIP benefits are a defined part of your policy. They are designed to cover specific, immediate needs following a crash.

• 80% of your reasonable and necessary medical bills.
• 60% of your lost gross wages or earning capacity.
• A $5,000 death benefit.

These benefits are capped at $10,000 in total. For a serious injury, this amount is exhausted very quickly, which is why a claim against the at-fault driver is necessary.

Making a claim against the at-fault driver’s insurance

This is the ideal scenario for protecting your insurance rates. When a law firm pursues a third-party claim on your behalf, it is demanding that the negligent driver’s insurance company pay for the damages their client caused. 

This includes your remaining medical bills, all of your lost wages, and compensation for your pain and suffering. Since your insurance company is not paying for this, the claim should have no impact on your premium.

Other Factors That Influence Post-Accident Rate Increases

An at-fault accident does not guarantee a rate hike, and a not-at-fault accident does not guarantee your rate stays the same. Insurers look at a broad profile to determine your level of risk.

The severity of the accident

The financial scope of the accident matters. An at-fault fender-bender in a parking lot that results in a $1,500 repair bill might be treated differently than a high-speed highway collision that totals two vehicles and results in a $100,000 injury settlement. 

The larger the payout your insurance company has to make, the more likely they are to see you as a significant financial risk, making a rate increase more probable.

Your prior driving record

Insurers believe that past behavior is a good predictor of future behavior. A driver with a spotless record for the past decade who has one minor at-fault accident may be treated with more leniency than a driver who has had three accidents and two speeding tickets in the last five years. 

A long history of safe driving demonstrates that the accident may have been an anomaly, not part of a pattern of risky behavior.

The concept of accident forgiveness

Some insurance companies offer a policy add-on called “accident forgiveness.” This is not a standard feature; it is an optional coverage that you must purchase and pay for as part of your premium. 

It typically means the insurer agrees not to raise your rates after your first at-fault accident. However, these programs come with specific rules and limitations that you must review carefully.

How a Lawyer Can Help Protect Your Financial Future

One of the most valuable services a personal injury lawyer provides is fighting to ensure fault is correctly assigned. This can directly protect you from an unfair and costly insurance rate increase.

Fighting incorrect fault determinations

Insurance adjusters may try to assign partial fault to you to reduce their payout, even when their driver was clearly negligent. They might claim you were speeding or that you made a sudden stop. Without evidence to the contrary, you could be stuck with a partial fault determination that triggers a rate hike.

An attorney proactively counters these tactics. A legal team can dispatch investigators to canvass nearby businesses for security camera footage that the police may have missed. They can locate and interview witnesses who saw the whole event. 

In a complex case, they can hire an accident reconstructionist to prove, using physics and engineering, that the crash could only have happened the way you described. This powerful evidence can force an insurer to accept 100% of the fault, protecting both your personal injury claim and your insurance record.

The Problem with AI for Insurance Questions

You could ask an AI tool if your rates will go up, and it will give you a generic, non-committal answer. What it cannot do is analyze the specifics of your crash in the context of Florida law and your insurance policy.

An AI cannot interpret the fine print of your “accident forgiveness” clause or assess the strength of the evidence against the other driver. It cannot predict how a specific insurer, like Progressive or GEICO, might treat a PIP-only claim versus a major liability claim in the Tampa Bay market. 

Relying on an algorithm for advice on a topic with so many variables is a gamble. For guidance based on real-world experience, you need a human professional.

FAQ About Car Accidents and Insurance Rates

What if the at-fault driver is uninsured? Will my rates go up if I use my Uninsured Motorist coverage?

Using your Uninsured Motorist (UM) coverage should not cause your rates to go up. UM is a coverage you pay for to protect yourself from irresponsible drivers. 

You are making a claim because another person was negligent and broke the law by driving without insurance. It is a not-at-fault claim, and Florida law generally prohibits insurers from raising rates for these claims.

Should I report a very minor accident with no injuries to my insurance company?

This is a tricky question. Most insurance policies require you to report all accidents. Failing to do so could give them grounds to deny coverage later if the other driver decides to claim an injury. 

However, reporting a very minor at-fault accident could lead to a rate increase. Speaking with an attorney for a free consultation can help you weigh the pros and cons for your specific situation.

How long does an at-fault accident stay on my insurance record?

In Florida, an at-fault accident will typically affect your insurance rates for three to five years. After this period, it should no longer be used as a primary factor in calculating your premium, assuming you have maintained a clean driving record since the incident.

Can I switch insurance companies to avoid a rate hike after an at-fault accident?

You can always switch insurance companies, but it may not help you avoid a higher rate. When you apply for a new policy, the new insurer will pull your driving record from a database. They will see the recent at-fault accident and will factor that into the premium they quote you.

Take Control of the Narrative

You do not have to be a passive victim of an insurance company’s calculations. By taking the right steps, you can actively protect yourself from an unfair assignment of fault and a resulting rate increase. 

An experienced personal injury attorney can be your strongest advocate in this process. The team at Roman Austin Personal Injury Lawyers is ready to fight for you.
Contact us today for a free, no-obligation case evaluation. We will analyze the facts of your accident and explain how we can work to protect your financial future. Call us at (727) 787-2500 or complete our online contact form to get started.